Talk:Split salamander brooch


 * I'm thinking that the main topic should be "Salamander badge" with "Split salamander brooch" as a subtitle instead, which also allows to put spoiler tags in front of the split one. What do you think? GhostNWN 20:13, 4 July 2008 (UTC)
 * Makes more sense to me if Salamander badges at least has it's own article. The split one is a quest item; the badges pile up in inventory/storage.  I remember checking here once to see where to get rid of the ones I had after talking to Leuvaarden's messenger.  While I did manage to figure out what I wanted to know (Can I get any money for these?  Need I bother to hang onto them?) it wasn't as straightforward as it could've been.  Licensed Luny 21:39, 4 July 2008 (UTC)


 * I've wrestled with this particular issue for a while. My reasoning was as follows: as Luny said, the split brooch is a quest item and all quest items have their own page which uses the name from the infobox popup in the game. I understand completely about the need for users to get all the information about these badges which is why i had added more information. The extra clarification is great, can't hurt at all imho. My only suggestion is that perhaps i haven't done enough redirects for this page, so if you think up more likely search terms and redirect them to the page. Two pages just seems overboard to me Game widow 10:10, 5 July 2008 (UTC)