Father Knows Worst

Father Knows Worst is a secondary quest in the Blood and Wine expansion.




 * We wish to hire a person (or persons) with good weapon skills who, for a reasonable fee, will escort us into Albertus Cavern for exploratory purposes. The knights errant claim the cave harbors no dangers, so we don't expect trouble, but better safe than sorry.


 * Auguste, Lucien and Hugo Monnart

Journal entry

 * One day, while strolling through Beauclair's bustling streets, Geralt spotted a notice – someone was in need off [sic] an escort as they wished to penetrate a cave. The task seemed none too complicated or taxing, so the witcher concluded it would be unwise to let it pass.


 * Before speaking to the posters of the notice, Geralt set out to do a bit of reconnaissance. Yet he returned to them quickly to find out what the job was to entail. The brothers, trembling in fear, explained that their other brother, beset by monsters, was trapped in a nearby cave.


 * Geralt followed a trail of blood to find Hugo. Wounded by monsters, the man had sought shelter in the cave's depths.


 * If Geralt attacks Hugo's brothers:
 * As Geralt and Hugo headed for the exit out of the none-too-hospitable caverns, Hugo's two brothers and a handful of armed men blocked their way. Fearing for his life, Hugo begged the witcher to teach his treacherous bastard brothers a lesson. Deciding that he should see the matter through to the end, Geralt fulfilled Hugo's wish.


 * If Geralt reasons with Hugo's brothers:
 * As Geralt and Hugo were leaving the none-too-hospitable caverns, Hugo's two siblings, assisted by a handful of armed men, blocked their way. Fearing for his life, Hugo begged the witcher to teach his treacherous bastard brothers a lesson. Yet as we all know, Geralt has a strong aversion for unnecessary violence, so he turned Hugo down. This proved a wise decision - forced to discuss their differences, the three brothers settled their dispute and resolved to embark on an enterprise together.

Walkthrough
Geralt finds the filter but tries to exit cave without giving it to Hugo:
 * Talk to the men issuing the contract.
 * Find out what happened to the missing brother.
 * Defeat the kikimores.
 * Using your Witcher Senses, look for signs of Hugo.
 * Follow the trail.
 * Talk to Hugo. (7 )
 * Letter to Martina Crisca can be found on a female body near the pool in the cave system.
 * Retrieve the missing part from the lake.
 * Still filter
 * Hugo catches up with Geralt and takes the filter.

Geralt finds filter and returns it to Hugo directly:
 * Return the filter to Hugo. (150, 100 )
 * There Can Be Only One, Geralt earns the virtue of honor (at end of quest).

Geralt attacks Hugo's brothers:
 * 150

Geralt reasons with Hugo's brothers:
 * 150, 300
 * Visit The Clever Clogs for alcohol at reduced prices. Turns Hugo into a merchant there.

Gallery
Vater weiß es ... eben nicht Mon père avait tort La dura verità Braterska miłość